“What deal has the highest cash-on-cash?”
When we’re talking to newbie investors, that’s one of the most common questions we hear.
Investors only want to see the deals with the highest cash-on-cash or the highest cap rate. They’re looking for the highest overall risk-adjusted returns for their CRE allocations, but they’re not considering all of the other factors that contribute to those returns. Why? We believe there’s a simple reason: They just don’t know how to (yet). This article teaches them how.
Tony Hershman, Custom Capital’s Managing Director of Acquisitions, has spent more than three decades in commercial real estate. Across his career, he’s been involved in more than $4 billion of commercial real estate transactions. About 10 years ago, he started explaining returns using a simple metaphor: a table with four legs. Those four legs are cash-on-cash, loan paydown, appreciation, and tax benefits.
In this article, we’ll show new accredited investors how to analyze commercial real estate deals for maximum returns.
Note: All investments come with risk. This article mainly deals with how to compare deals with the highest returns, but generally there’s a relationship between risk and return. Always talk to your CPA and financial advisor before making any investment decision.
Key Takeaways
- ▸The deals with the highest overall returns aren’t necessarily the deals with the highest cash-on-cash or highest cap rates.
- ▸When you use leverage to buy a commercial property, you can generate returns from: cash flow, appreciation from built-in rent escalators, loan paydown, and tax benefits.
- ▸All of these contribute to your overall returns.
- ▸In our illustrative example, roughly 7% average cash on cash grows to about 19% a year once all four legs are counted.
Why Do Investors Get Stuck on One Number?
A lot of newbie commercial real estate guides teaches investors to ask about cash-on-cash and cap rate. More specifically: “What is the highest cap rate or cash on cash deal available?” If they’re a little bit more advanced, some investors ask, “What deal has the highest Y1 tax deduction?” These are valid questions, assuming that those deals fit your risk profile. Still, as Tony puts it, “it’s only one leg of the table.”
Consider this: An investor likes a property with a 7% cash on cash return, but holds out for 8%. On paper, that looks like a choice between 7% and 8% (obviously). In reality, that deal might offer great tax benefits (like the retail motor fuel outlets you can read about in our gas station guide) that more than make up for the slightly lower cash-on-cash. You shouldn’t hold out just because one number doesn’t match up with what you think it should be.
“Take one or two legs of the table away, and the deal falls over.” (Tony Hershman, Managing Director of Acquisitions)
Watch: Tony Hershman on the Four Legs
Leg One: Cash-on-Cash
Cash on cash return is the rent left over after the mortgage, divided by the cash the investor put in. It is the most visible leg because it’s your take-home pay and therefore the easiest number to understand.
Under an absolute NNN lease, the tenant typically pays property taxes, insurance, and maintenance. As a result, landlord responsibilities are very low. A double net (NN) lease may leave the roof and structure with the landlord but generally, as Tony notes, a roof might need work only once a decade. A well chosen NN deal can come close to NNN economics.
Compare that with a rental home or a small apartment building. There, the owner pays for the water heater, the roof leak, and every rise in taxes or insurance. Those surprises make returns hard to forecast. In contrast, net lease income tends to be steady and easy to model.
Leg Two: Appreciation
Most commercial leases include fixed rent increases, often 2% a year or a step-up every five years. When rent rises and the cap rate stays the same, the property’s value rises with it. Why? Because many investors purchase commercial property since it produces income.
Tony explains it with simple math. If the rent goes from $1.00 to $1.10 and buyers still price the property at the same cap rate, the building is worth about 10% more. In other words, the increase is written into the lease rather than left to the market.
Quick Self Check
Is Your Table Missing a Leg?
Are you a newbie investor or do you already understand this concept? Test your knowledge here…
Question 1 of 3
When you size up a deal, which number do you look at first?
Educational only. Not investment, tax, or legal advice.
This is also why we model appreciation conservatively. Our projections assume the property sells at the same cap rate it was bought at. They do not count on market growth or a lower exit cap rate. For context, single tenant net lease cap rates averaged 6.92% in Q3 2026, according to The Boulder Group, up 10 basis points from the prior quarter.
Leg Three: Loan Paydown
Loan paydown is the part of each mortgage payment that reduces the loan balance. The tenant’s rent covers that payment, so the investor’s equity grows every month.
Think of it as a savings account the investor cannot spend yet. The loan balance goes down and down, while equity goes up and up. That money comes back at a sale or a refinance.
The size of this leg depends on the loan terms. Commercial loans commonly amortize over 25 to 30 years, with a fixed period of five, seven, or ten years. In addition, permanent loan rates for 25 year fixed terms ran about 6.75% to 7.50% in Q2 2026. Better terms mean more of each payment goes to principal sooner. This is one reason Custom Capital built a programmatic institutional lending facility, which gives individual investors terms approved in advance, closer to what an institution would get.
Leg Four: Tax Benefits
Depreciation lets owners deduct the cost of a building over time, even while the property earns income. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act made 100% bonus depreciation permanent for qualifying property acquired after January 19, 2025. Paired with a cost segregation study, that can move a large deduction into year one.
Some asset types benefit more than others. Most commercial buildings depreciate over 39 years. However, a gas station that qualifies as a retail motor fuels outlet can depreciate over 15 years instead. Generally, the property qualifies if at least half of its revenue or floor space comes from fuel sales, or if the store is 1,400 square feet or smaller (KBKG explains the tests). That shorter life makes much of the building eligible for bonus depreciation. We cover the details in our guide to 100% bonus depreciation for NNN investors.
How an investor uses the deduction matters, too. Rental income is passive by default. Under the passive activity loss rules, passive losses generally offset only passive income. Even so, that alone can shelter the property’s own cash flow for several years. Investors who qualify for real estate professional status may also offset active income, though many busy professionals will not qualify. Tax situations vary widely, so this is the one leg each investor should calculate with a CPA.
Putting the Four Legs Together: A Worked Example
The numbers below are illustrative only. They are rounded, simplified, and not a projection for any specific property. Still, they show how four modest figures can add up to a large one. The setup resembles a gas station deal we walked through on a recent webinar (our overview of gas station real estate covers the asset class in more depth).
Illustrative scenario:
Property: a $1.7 million gas station on a new 20 year absolute NNN lease, bought at an 8% cap rate (about $136,000 of rent in year one) with 2% annual escalators.
Financing: 35% down ($595,000), with the rest borrowed at 7.5% and amortized over 25 years.
Cash on cash: cash flow starts near $38,000 and grows to about $49,000 by year five. That averages roughly 7.3% a year on the equity.
Appreciation: at the same 8% cap rate, the higher rent supports a sale price near $1.88 million. That gain of about $177,000 works out to roughly 5.9% a year.
Loan paydown: the balance falls by about $91,000 over five years, or roughly 3.1% a year.
Tax benefits: if depreciation shelters the property’s cash flow from a 37% tax rate, the savings come to about $81,000, or roughly 2.7% a year.
Added together, the four legs produce about $567,000 over five years. Spread evenly, that is roughly 19% a year on the $595,000 invested, before selling costs. The investor focused only on the 7% cash on cash would have seen barely more than a third of the picture.
Common mistake: judging a deal by one leg. Passing on a property because cash on cash is 7% instead of 8% may cost one point of cash flow while giving up a total return several times larger.
This simple average is not an internal rate of return (IRR), and it does not account for the timing of each dollar. We explain how our deal numbers are built, line by line, on every property we present. As Tony puts it, there are many formulas investors use, and the important thing is knowing exactly what is included.
Where Does the Four Legs Framework Fall Short?
Every number above is a projection, not a guarantee. A balanced view means looking at what could break the table, too.
The tenant is the biggest risk. A roof or an air conditioner can be replaced. A tenant that goes out of business, on the other hand, can stop income until the space is leased again. That is why lease structure matters so much. A corporate guarantee from an operator with many locations may protect the rent at a single site, as long as the company stays solvent.
Tax benefits are deferred, not erased. Depreciation may be recaptured when a property sells. Many owners use a 1031 exchange to roll into the next property and keep deferring, but that is a strategy to plan, not a given.
Other investments have their place. Public REITs offer daily liquidity, and stock index funds have had a strong run. Syndications offer access to larger assets. However, investors in a syndication generally rely on the sponsor for timing, operations, and exits, as we cover in our guide to real estate syndications. By comparison, 100% direct ownership leaves those decisions with the owner.
Lastly, not every property delivers all four legs equally. A deal with a high cap rate but a weak tenant, a short lease, or no escalators may score well on one leg and poorly on the rest.
Final Thoughts: The Bottom Line on Commercial Real Estate for Accredited Investors
A single number rarely tells the whole story of a commercial deal. Cash on cash shows the income. Appreciation, loan paydown, and tax benefits show where much of the remaining return comes from. Looking at all four legs together gives a fuller and more honest picture of what a property may earn.
For accredited investors weighing commercial real estate, the four legs offer a simple way to compare deals side by side. Custom Capital has closed $470M+ in real estate across 135+ deals, and every property we present breaks out all four legs so investors and their CPAs can check the math. If you’d like to see how the framework applies to your goals, our process starts with a conversation.
See All Four Legs on a Real Deal
Our team breaks out cash flow, appreciation, loan paydown, and tax benefits on every property we present, so you and your CPA can check the math before you commit.
All projections are estimates, not guarantees. Real estate investing involves risk, including the loss of principal. Consult your own tax advisor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the four legs of the table in commercial real estate?
The four legs are cash on cash return, appreciation, loan paydown, and tax benefits. Together they make up the total return of a leveraged commercial property. Tony Hershman, Custom Capital’s Managing Director of Acquisitions, uses the image to show why one metric alone can mislead investors.
Why isn’t cap rate enough to evaluate a commercial property?
Cap rate shows the property’s income relative to its price, but it ignores financing, rent growth, and taxes. Two properties with the same cap rate can produce very different total returns. Lease length, escalators, and tenant credit often matter as much as the cap rate itself.
How do rent escalators create appreciation?
When rent rises and buyers price the property at the same cap rate, the value rises by the same percentage. For example, a 10% increase in rent supports roughly a 10% higher value at a constant cap rate. Many net lease portfolios carry annual increases around 2%.
Can depreciation from commercial real estate offset W-2 income?
Generally, no. Rental losses are passive and typically offset only passive income, such as the property’s own cash flow. Investors who qualify for real estate professional status and materially participate may offset active income, so it is worth reviewing with a CPA.
Why do gas stations get better depreciation than other commercial properties?
A gas station that qualifies as a retail motor fuels outlet can depreciate over 15 years instead of 39. That makes much of the building eligible for 100% bonus depreciation, which the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made permanent for property acquired after January 19, 2025. Qualification generally depends on fuel revenue, floor space, or store size.
