Do you already know the five 1031 exchange mistakes that trip up investors most often?
As a private family office that takes care of sourcing, financing, and closing on commercial properties on behalf of our buyers, we’re well versed in helping buyers with 1031 exchanges. Over the years, we’ve seen the same handful of 1031 exchange mistakes come up again and again.
Those mistakes are costly. An estimated 8% to 10% of 1031 exchanges fail to complete, according to the National Association of Realtors. When an exchange fails, the deferred gain generally becomes taxable right away. These mistakes can cost investors hundreds of thousands (sometimes millions) of dollars — so it pays to know them.
A Quick Refresher on the Rules
In this article, we assume you know the basics of 1031 exchanges. If you don’t, our complete guide to the 1031 exchange is a great place to start. Here’s a quick overview:
Engage a qualified intermediary first. You need to engage a qualified intermediary (QI) before your sale closes.
Identify within 45 days. You have 45 days after closing to identify a replacement property.
Close within 180 days. You have 180 days after closing to close on the replacement property.
With that in mind, let’s see how well you know the most common pitfalls.
Quick Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
Do you already know these common 1031 exchange mistakes? Test your knowledge.
1. When does a qualified intermediary need to be in place?
A) Within 45 days after the sale closes
B) Before the sale of the old property closes
C) Any time before buying the replacement property
Reveal the answer
Answer: B. The intermediary has to be in place before the sale closes. After that, it is generally too late.
2. Under the most common identification rule, how many replacement properties can you name?
A) Only one
B) Up to three, no matter what they cost
C) As many as you like
Reveal the answer
Answer: B. You can name up to three properties of any value. Most investors use the extra spots as backups.
3. Sale proceeds land in your personal checking account for one day. What happens?
A) Nothing, as long as the money goes to the intermediary within a week
B) The exchange generally fails
C) The IRS charges a small penalty
Reveal the answer
Answer: B. Touching the money, even briefly, generally counts as receiving it, which usually makes the sale taxable.
4. You sell a property for $1.5M and buy one for $1.3M, with no debt on either. What is the $200,000 difference called?
A) Boot
B) Basis
C) Recapture
Reveal the answer
Answer: A. Boot is the cash or other value you keep from the exchange. The IRS generally taxes your gain up to that amount.
5. Day 180 falls on a Sunday. When is the real deadline?
A) The following Monday
B) That Sunday, so plan to close before the weekend
C) The IRS adds 30 days automatically
Reveal the answer
Answer: B. The deadlines count calendar days and do not move for weekends or holidays, so plan to close by Friday.
Key Takeaways
- ▸Most failed exchanges trace back to a few avoidable 1031 exchange mistakes, and an estimated 8% to 10% of exchanges fail to complete in a timely manner.
- ▸A qualified intermediary has to be engaged before the sale closes, and the proceeds should never touch your own accounts.
- ▸Naming backup properties within the 45 day window can protect the exchange if the first deal falls through.
- ▸Boot (cash or debt relief you keep) is taxable, and the 180 day deadline almost never moves.
1031 Exchange Mistake #1: Not Identifying Multiple Properties
Naming only one replacement property leaves no fallback if that deal falls apart. Under the IRS identification rules, investors can generally name up to three properties of any value. Most investors use those extra spots as backups, which can keep the exchange alive if the first choice collapses.
The rules for this come straight from the Treasury regulations on deferred exchanges. Investors can follow one of three options:
The three property rule. Name up to three properties, no matter what they cost. This is by far the most common choice.
The 200% rule. Name any number of properties, as long as their combined value stays within 200% of the property you sold.
The 95% rule. Name more than that, but only if you actually buy at least 95% of the total value you identified. This one is rarely used.

A qualified intermediary will not advise you on what to identify as a replacement property. This article is general education, and we will not advise specific investors on what to identify as their replacement properties, either.
However, it’s a good practice to identify a backup so that you don’t have to foot the bill if your first choice falls through. Deals fall apart for all kinds of reasons, such as a failed inspection, a lender delay, or a seller who changes their mind. With only one property on the list, any of these can sink the whole exchange. Our guide to choosing a 1031 replacement property walks through what to look for.
Custom Capital does not provide tax, legal, or qualified intermediary services, and nothing in this article is advice on which properties a specific investor should identify. Consult a qualified tax professional before making any exchange decision.
Mistake #2: Not Setting Up Your Exchange Before Closing
This is one of the most costly 1031 exchange mistakes. Every once in a while, an investor will approach us after closing and ask how they can do a 1031 exchange. By then, it’s already too late.
A 1031 exchange has to be set up before the sale of the old property closes. A qualified intermediary needs to hold the proceeds from day one. If the sale closes and the money goes to the seller first, the IRS generally treats it as a regular, taxable sale.
The fix is simple, but it takes a little planning. As soon as a sale looks likely, reach out to a qualified intermediary and get the exchange agreement signed. Most intermediaries can set things up quickly. Even so, it’s best not to leave it until the week of closing.
The cost of setting up an exchange is usually small compared to the tax at stake. We broke down the numbers in our article on how much a 1031 exchange costs.
Talk Through Your Exchange Timeline →

Mistake #3: Allowing Proceeds Into a Business or Personal Account
This goes hand in hand with the point above. Most QIs will closely assist you with this, but it’s very important that the money involved in your exchange remains with your intermediary until it’s used to buy the replacement property.

Investors cannot be in “actual or constructive receipt” of the sale proceeds, as The Tax Adviser explains. In plain terms, that means you can’t hold the money, and you can’t have the right to take it, either. If the funds land in your personal or business account, even for a day, the exchange generally fails.
This mistake often happens by accident. A title company may not realize the sale is part of an exchange, so it wires the proceeds straight to the seller. That’s why it helps to tell everyone involved (your broker, your title company, and your attorney) about the exchange early on.
A common trap. Some investors plan to “park” the money in a business account for a few days. Even with the best intentions, this usually counts as receiving the funds.
Mistake #4: Getting Boot
Boot is any cash or value you keep from the exchange instead of reinvesting it. The IRS generally taxes your gain up to the amount of boot received, according to its tax tips on like kind exchanges. The rest of the exchange can still qualify, but that portion becomes taxable.

Essentially, this happens if you aren’t buying a property of equal or greater value. It can leave you with a large and unexpected tax bill. We cover the details in our article on 1031 exchange boot, but here are the two most common types:
Cash boot. This happens when the replacement property costs less than the one you sold, or when you keep some of the proceeds.
Mortgage boot. This happens when you pay off a loan on the old property but take on less debt for the new one, without adding cash to cover the gap.
Illustrative scenario:
An investor sells a property for $1.5 million with no mortgage. They then buy a replacement property for $1.3 million, also with no debt.
The $200,000 left over is boot. The IRS generally taxes the investor’s gain up to that $200,000, even though the rest of the exchange is still deferred.
To fully defer the tax, investors generally need to buy property of equal or greater value, reinvest all of the net proceeds, and replace any debt they paid off. On the other hand, some investors take a small amount of boot on purpose because they want cash on hand. That can be fine, as long as they plan for the tax.
Mistake #5: Missing Deadlines
Life gets busy, but the IRS offers almost no leeway with the deadlines. Investors have 45 days to identify a replacement property and 180 days to close. Both clocks start the day the old property sells, and they run at the same time.

There’s also a lesser known catch. Under the Treasury regulations, the exchange period actually ends on day 180 or on your tax return due date (including extensions), whichever comes first. For a sale late in the year, that can cut the window short unless you file an extension.
On top of that, the deadlines count calendar days. They don’t roll forward for weekends or holidays. The main exception is IRS relief for federally declared disasters, which only applies in specific cases.
Waiting on financing. A loan that closes late can push the purchase past day 180. Lining up financing early is one of the best ways to protect the timeline.
If you don’t engage professional help with your 1031 exchange, you could have a lot of problems with it. This is one reason we focus on planning early. Our team pairs vetted, off market NNN properties with a programmatic institutional lending facility, which can help exchange buyers close within tight IRS windows.
Final Thoughts: Avoiding the Top 1031 Exchange Mistakes
A 1031 exchange can be one of the most powerful tax tools available to real estate investors. However, it only works if you follow the rules closely.
Most 1031 exchange mistakes come down to planning. Set up your exchange before closing, keep the money with your intermediary, name backup properties, and watch both deadlines closely. It also helps to plan for boot so it doesn’t catch you by surprise.
Custom Capital has acquired $470M+ in real estate across 135+ transactions, and many of our buyers come to us in the middle of an exchange. That’s one reason so many investors see NNN properties as the ideal 1031 replacement. If you’re planning a 1031 exchange, we’d be glad to walk through your timeline with you well before your sale closes.
Planning a 1031 Exchange?
Schedule a call with our team to talk through your exchange timeline and the NNN properties we source through our broker channels.
Custom Capital does not provide tax, legal, or qualified intermediary services. Consult a qualified tax professional before making any exchange decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most common 1031 exchange mistake?
Missed deadlines and poor timing are the most common 1031 exchange mistakes. Investors generally have 45 days to identify a replacement property and 180 days to close, and the IRS rarely extends either one. Setting up the exchange early and naming backup properties tends to prevent most timing problems.
Can I start a 1031 exchange after my sale has closed?
Generally, no. A qualified intermediary has to be in place before the sale of the old property closes, so the proceeds never reach the seller. Once the money has been received, the sale is usually treated as taxable.
How many replacement properties can I identify in a 1031 exchange?
Most investors use the three property rule, which allows up to three properties of any value. The 200% rule allows more properties, as long as their combined value stays within 200% of the property sold. A third option, the 95% rule, is rarely used.
Is boot always a mistake?
Not always. Some investors take a small amount of cash on purpose and accept the tax on it. The IRS generally taxes gain up to the amount of boot received, so the key is planning for it rather than being surprised by it.
Can the 45 day or 180 day deadline be extended?
Generally, no. The deadlines count calendar days and do not move for weekends or holidays. The main exception is IRS relief for federally declared disasters, which applies only in specific situations.