1031 Exchange Ohio
1031 Exchange in Ohio: Off-Market NNN Replacement Properties
Own your replacement property outright and start generating income from month one. Custom Capital sources off-market single-tenant NNN properties for accredited investors completing a 1031 exchange in Ohio. We handle the diligence, financing, and close within the 45- and 180-day deadlines.
- 45 days to identify
- 180 days to close
$470M
130+
40+
100%
Our Current Ohio Replacement Inventory Is Off-Market.
We share our current Ohio replacement inventory privately with accredited exchangers on a call rather than listing it on a public page. The strongest net lease deals often trade before they ever hit the market. Sourcing those properties is a major part of what our acquisitions team does.
How a 1031 Exchange Works in Ohio
Section 1031 sets the rules for an Ohio exchange of one real estate property for another. It lets an investor sell their investment real estate and acquire a qualifying replacement property. To qualify, the investor cannot take possession of the sale proceeds. Instead, a qualified intermediary, which is a third party, holds the money until it is used to purchase the replacement property. This allows the investor to defer the capital gains tax on the sale.
The Ohio tax treatment adds a state layer to the exchange. The state does not have a separate capital gains rate. It taxes gains as ordinary income on the individual return. Did you know: there is no distinction between short-term and long-term gains for state tax purposes. Beginning in tax year 2026, Ohio applies a flat 2.75% rate to nonbusiness income above $26,050. An Ohio seller is therefore deferring more than federal tax; the state layer is deferred too.
Income determines whether a long-term gain is taxed federally:
- 0%
- 15%
- Or 20%
A separate Net Investment Income Tax (3.8%) may apply for higher earners as well. A large gain may face a blended federal rate near 23.8% before depreciation recapture and roughly 26.5% after Ohio tax is included. A 1031 exchange allows that full equity to keep compounding in real estate.
Understanding the Ohio Rules
There is no separate Ohio timeline for the exchange. To qualify, the property must be held for investment or used in a business. Once the sale closes, two deadlines begin at the same time: 45 days to identify the replacement in writing and 180 days to close on it. Weekends and holidays do not extend either deadline. To defer the entire gain, the replacement property should match or exceed the value and debt of the relinquished property. If the investor takes cash out, that cash is considered boot and is taxable on both the federal and Ohio returns.
Where to Reinvest: Comparing Ohio Metros for a 1031
Ohio’s three largest metros are similar in size but behave differently as investment markets. Cincinnati leads in population, Columbus stands out for growth, and Cleveland offers the widest going-in yields at the lowest basis. Toledo, Akron, and Dayton sit in a secondary tier, where cap rates tend to run higher.
Metro
Growth Signal (2024 – 2025)
Net Lease Demand
Underwriting Note
Columbus
Franklin County posted Ohio’s largest county increase, adding about 8,880 residents; Delaware County gained about 5,169.
Retail, fuel and convenience, and service tenants following new rooftops along exurban growth corridors.
Expect the state's lowest caps on credit tenants here because of the tight pricing in Ohio
Cincinnati
City grew ~1.5% from 2020 to 2025, Ohio’s largest metro with ~2.31 million
Broad demand for essential retail, medical, and QSR properties across a stable, diversified base.
Submarket selection carries more weight than metro-level growth
Cleveland
~2.17 million; Cuyahoga County ranks near the bottom of the state for growth since 2020
Necessity retail in a market with under 5% vacancy and little construction underway.
The state’s lowest basis and widest yields, with tenant credit and residual value carrying more weight than appreciation.
Dayton / Akron / Toledo
Montgomery County added over 2,500 residents; Lucas County fell by the most in the state
Essential retail and service anchoring established, slower-growth corridors
Secondary-market pricing, with lease term and guarantor strength doing most of the work.
Columbus
Cincinnati
Cleveland
Dayton / Akron / Toledo
These demographic and cap rate figures reflect market averages, not every property. Asset quality, tenant credit, and lease terms can change the numbers.
The replacement property does not need to be in the same metro as the property sold. It can be located in another state as well. Therefore, an Ohio 1031 exchange can weigh deals in Columbus, Cincinnati, and Cleveland side by side, but also move capital out of Ohio entirely. More than one metro also gives the investor useful backups before the 45-day deadline.
Why Ohio Draws 1031 Exchange Capital
Since 2020, Ohio’s counties have split evenly, with 44 gaining population and 44 losing it. Between 2024 and 2025, the state added nearly 40,000 residents. This was a 0.34% increase. It ranks 36th among states for growth over the past decade.
Ohio’s appeal comes down to two drivers: yield and capital investment.
Did you know: business investment is moving into Ohio even where population growth is limited. By 2030, data center investments might increase by tens of billions. AWS has committed $10 billion across up to eight sites in Ohio, beginning with property it purchased next to the Honda-LG battery plant in Fayette County. Google is also adding data centers in Columbus and Lancaster. These projects bring workers, contractors, and daytime demand — the kind of activity that supports fuel stations, convenience stores, and quick-service restaurants.
Licking County’s Ohio One campus has been pushed to 2030 and 2031. It may be a long-term catalyst, but it is a poor basis for a projection. Our underwriting does not rely on that project.
Yield is the other part of Ohio’s investment case. Single-tenant net lease retail in Ohio and the surrounding Midwest generally trades 50 to 150 basis points wider than the national average. The spread can translate into more replacement income for an exchanger. Ohio often offers the same tenant credit at a lower cost.
Know the Deadline, Plan Your Ohio Exchange
Start with the date your property sale closes. We will project the 45- and 180-day deadlines and a recommended off-market sourcing start date.
Recommended: before the sale closes
Written identification deadline
Replacement acquisition deadline
Ohio has a thinner supply of credit-tenant, long-lease net lease properties than many Sun Belt markets. With only 45 days to identify a replacement, waiting until the sale closes can leave you with fewer options. An early start improves your chances of finding more than one qualifying replacement property.
How Custom Capital Sources Ohio Replacements
A strong Ohio 1031 exchange partner should do more than handle paperwork. Investors also need off-market inventory and the ability to close before the deadline. Many Ohio 1031 companies focus on holding funds between transactions. Custom Capital takes a different role by sourcing and delivering the replacement property itself.
Off-market sourcing carries more weight in Ohio, where net lease inventory runs thinner. Did you know: less than a tenth of available single-tenant retail nationally is investment-grade with a long lease term. Secondary-market listings often lean toward shorter terms and franchisee guarantors. The credit-tenant deal at a Midwest cap rate is more likely to be found off market.
Net lease properties can fit an exchange timeline well. With an NNN lease, the tenant covers:
- Insurance
- Taxes
- Maintenance
That keeps the owner’s day-to-day responsibilities lighter without giving up full ownership of the building.
Off-Market Access
Pre-vetted single-tenant NNN across Ohio
100+ Checkpoints
Diligence review before we bring anything to you.
Programmatic Debt
Institutional financing through 40+ lenders.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I Owe Ohio State Tax on a 1031 Exchange Gain?
An improperly structured exchange can create Ohio tax. The state has no distinct capital gains rate; instead, the gain is taxed as ordinary income on the individual return. Ohio’s 2026 rate is a flat 2.75% on nonbusiness income over $26,050, and long-term gains receive no preferred rate. The federal capital gains bill sits on top of that amount. When the exchange is completed correctly, the investor defers both tax layers. Texas and Florida have no state income tax, so exchangers there are deferring the federal tax only.
What Are the 1031 Exchange Rules in Ohio?
The governing rules come from federal Section 1031. Ohio accepts that framework and has no additional state exchange procedure. To qualify, the property needs an investment or business purpose. The replacement must be identified in writing within 45 days and acquired within 180 days. You cannot take possession of the sale proceeds; they must move through a qualified intermediary. If the replacement does not cover enough value and debt, the cash removed as boot is taxable on both the federal and Ohio returns. Budget for conveyance fees on both sides of an Ohio exchange. Did you know: there is a conveyance fee of $1 per $1,000 of value charged by the state. Additionally, the county has a fee. It runs $1 to $4 per $1,000, and it applies to both legs of the exchange. Withholding on sales by nonresident sellers is not required by Ohio. Therefore, out-of-state exchangers are not locking up closing capital.
Can I Do a 1031 Exchange in Columbus, Cincinnati, or Cleveland?
Yes. One metro to the next, the rules stay the same because 1031 is federal. That means that Ohio cities and/or counties do not add identification or closing requirements. The location changes the available inventory and pricing, not whether the exchange qualifies. Columbus has the tightest pricing for credit tenants, Cincinnati sits in the middle, and Cleveland and the secondary markets trade wider at a lower basis. We typically identify options in multiple Ohio metros. With limited long-lease inventory backed by credit tenants, narrowing the search to one city creates unnecessary risk during the 45-day period.
Can I Exchange an Ohio Property for One in Another State, or Move Outside Capital Into Ohio?
Yes, you can exchange out of Ohio or bring outside capital into the state. Any U.S. investment real estate is considered like-kind to other U.S. investment real estate. This means that you can exchange an Ohio property for one in another state. Unlike a handful of states, Ohio stops tracking the deferred gain once it leaves and has no clawback rule. For capital moving into the state, yield is the attraction, since comparable tenant credit usually prices wider than it does in the Sun Belt. Buying the replacement property in Ohio can create a state filing requirement for a nonresident, even when the return shows no tax due.
NNN or DST for an Ohio 1031?
A single-tenant NNN property gives:
- 100% ownership
- Direct control
- Low landlord duties
The tenant carries:
- Taxes
- Insurance
- Maintenance
DST investors own a fraction of the asset and do not control it. That structure can use remaining exchange equity, though it is not a substitute for whole-building ownership. For many Ohio exchanges, the NNN asset is the primary purchase and the DST covers any leftover amount.
What Do 1031 Exchange Companies in Ohio Do, and How Does Custom Capital Help?
The services depend on the company. A qualified intermediary may limit its role to holding the proceeds between transactions. Property sourcing is a separate role. As a private family office, Custom Capital finds pre-vetted single-tenant NNN properties before they reach the market. Each property is underwritten, financed through institutional sources, and guided through closing within 180 days. Ownership of the completed asset belongs entirely to the investor. Custom Capital has acquired more than $470M in property. The goal is to place exchange capital into a durable, income-producing asset before time runs out.